Is there a distinct line between type-2 diabetic and non-diabetic or is there a fuzzy zone where you can go either way?

My wife in not overweight, 22.7 BMI. She had a FBS of 6.1(110) at the Lab and passed the OGTT because she had a reactive hypoglycemic reaction. She got an A1c of 5.6%. However, give her a glass of orange juice and she hits 200+ real fast.

Our Doctor has not marked her as diabetic, but has written an Rx for test-strips which I consider is very thoughtful of him. His words were "Just watch it!". One diabetic per house is enough. I have convinced her to cut the carbs and she does test quite a bit. She is on a half-ass version of Dr Bernstein because I am leaning on her to go in that direction. She is getting a lot of BGs under 6.0(108). Her mother was a T2 and I think my wife has got the message without freaking out.

I hate to see true T2 diabetics not diagnosed early enough to prevent damage. Also I'm not impressed with the "See your Doctor, take your meds" over simplification of treatment.

Views: 595

Replies are closed for this discussion.

Replies to This Discussion

Your wife is fortunate to have you to guide her. Tragic how many T2's coast along believing T2 is nothing (not the "bad" kind) & their doctors don't offer help or education. Not to mention the additional issue that the standards for diagnosing are too lax.

Good doctor to have prescribed strips. Heartbreaking for those who are told to test a couple of times a week, or less because that's all their doc or insurance will allow. A friend's T2 husband, with excellent insurance, was advised to test several times a month. His A1c isn't good, but he's not aware of this because his doc said he's fine. He dutifully takes Metformin & sadly believes that's all that is needed.

See your doctor, take your meds. Eye rolling at that as people's health declines.

T2 is a complicated disease. Nothing simple about trying to stay ahead of the eight ball.

I Agree 100% Gerri,

3 years ago after a routine blood test and a1c of 7.2 I was told to "cut down on rice and potatoes" and sent my way. No explanation, not medication, no test strips, no advice etc etc... I found this site and believe I've learned much more than my GP would ever know.

Paul

Paul,

It's criminal! Maleficence that should be malpractice. Wish patients would sue these doctors to get the attention of the medical community. Makes me militant.

I agree with this. I've had several friends "on the cusp" who seem to be told "you're ok" but actually are running numbers out of normal ranges but not enough to trigger a response from the medical industry.

We found out that my wife had a problem soon after my diagnosis when she tried out my meter one morning to see how it worked and out popped a 119 fasting. She has lost some weight and is very disciplined about daily exercise but isn't as disciplined as she might be about carbs. That's the downside of having a T1 husband who isn't a low carber.

Her "diagnosis" is pre-diabetes although she is growing convinced that she really has a well controlled case of T2 diabetes. Her primary did prescribe strips and sent her to a session with a very good CDE and a helpful nutritionist so I'm not complaining about her care. But if we weren't on top of it she would have been much further down the road before her primary took action.

Maurie

This topic has given me an idea. How about a Light Blue Day where we test partners, kids, friends?

The 2012 test strip feud has begun so I don't have any spare strips and am not sharing, unless it's somebody "on the team" who's in distress...

A "Light Blue Day" is a great idea, Gerri! I went so far as to get free meters with strips for my mother, sister and daughter, after my diagnosis. My daughter had some problematic numbers and has cut back on the carbs.

I gave a friend a meter. He's T2 with his head in the sand. Really worried about him. His doctor said he's hypoglycemic (not hardly from the tests I did showing him how to use the meter), so he's swilling Coke when he feels off. He's probably got reactive hypoglycemia.

There actually is NO distinct cutoff between normal, prediabetes and frank T2. The line is wherever the medical establishment decides to put it. A couple of decades ago, the diagnostic cutoff was 140, because a given percent of the population fell below that number (don't remember what the percent was).

Then some studies emerged, primarily on the Pima Indians of Arizona, but also on other populations, which showed that the incidence of diabetic complications, primarily retinopathy rose sharply at FBG somewhere around 120 - 130, so the powers that be decided to lower the diagnostic threshhold for diabetes to 126. They were cautious about not making it too low because they didn't want to treat people who really didn't need it.

Now, they're looking at A1c as a gold standard for diagnosis, based on studies of complications as well. Heart disease is a major issue for T2s and some of the decision will be based on CVD statistics. The number that they're going for is 6.5, which to me seems pretty high, all things considered, but they're not taking individual variation into account -- just looking at overall populations.

The concept of pre-diabetes is a fairly new one, and establishing the low end of the spectrum at 100 is pretty arbitrary, but at least people who have good doctors will know they're at risk, and have the chance to do something. Avoiding an actual diagnosis through good control habits is essentially the same thing as saying you've prevented or delayed it, and can have benefits, such as when you apply for insurance.

In my own case, if current guidelines had been applied, I would have been diagnosed 2 years earlier, sparing me a lot of agonizing over whether I did or didn't have diabetes. (The previous year, I definitely didn't) But in the end, the best advice was given me by my dearest friend: don't worry about whether you have diabetes or not -- live as if you did, because that means striving for a healthy diet and sufficient exercise and healthy living -- it can't hurt you and it CAN help!

Well, I think she's a candidate for both dietary control (no more fruit juice, carb counting/control and avoidance of "fast" or "simple" carbs), a serious exercise program (resistance and aerobic) and that she may benefit very soon from a very low dose of Metformin, if she can tolerate it.

I also had reactive hypoglycemia -- for decades -- before I was officially diagnosed with T2 -- an early red-flag warning of genetic difficulty with carbohydrate metabolism. I still get angry when I recall the snide way my (former!) doctor told me that I was "fine" when my 12-hour fasting BG went from 90 to 105 to 115 over a two-year period. I wasn't fine. I was sliding up into T2 and I should have been testing regularly at home, moderating carbs, etc. as soon as the creep started. Who knows what I was running after meals? No one was testing it so I have no idea. I do know that my first A1C -- taken after I finally passed the Magic Diabetic Threshold with a fasting above 126 -- was in the double digits!!! And I'd been complaining of blurry vision and trouble with my night vision for a couple of years before diagnosis. Gah.

At that time (in the four years leading up to diagnosis) I was very active in the local swing-dancing scene and was dancing (East Coast swing, Lindy Hop, Balboa and Salsa) upwards of 15 hours per week, plus lots of commuting on my bicycle. After my melanoma surgery on my foot, I couldn't walk for six months, much less dance. I gained a lot of weight, stopped exercising and -- tada -- was diagnosed with T2 one year after the melanoma surgery. If my doctors had actually cared about me, they would have suggested physical therapy and a substitute exercise program after my crippling foot surgery and they would have kept on top of my creeping blood glucose after I lost my ability to exercise vigorously.

Oh, well. Hind-sight is 20-20 and HMO's suck. We have to be pro-active these days because the new medical paradigm results in drive-by pseudo-medicine. No one is really watching out for us but ourselves and our families. Your wife is blessed to have you.

My wife went and had her A1c tested about two years ago. She blew a 5.8%. I informed her that she had diabetes. I wasn't very tactful and boy was she p***ed. She basically called me a liar and questioned why I thought I knew so much more than the dr. I was perhaps not as tactful as Alan. But in her heart, she knew what I was saying was true. By the time you reach the point of getting diagnosed with overt diabetes you have lost 80% of your beta cell function. This is straight from the mouth of Ralph DeFronzo, in his 2008 ADA Banting Award lecture.

In my view, as soon as you start to display blood sugar abnormalitities, you have diabetes. The healthy non-diabetic has plenty of reserve insulin capacity to keep their blood sugar rock steady at normal levels. Once your blood sugars start to waiver, something is terribly wrong.

My wife has since adopted a low carb diet, eating only the foods I prepare. And in the process lost a fair bit of weight. Her A1c is back in the normal range. She is successfully treating her condition with diet alone. As to whether she truly understands that she now has diabetes and will likely always have to treat it, I cannot say. At least for now she seems permanently committed to low carb.

RSS

Advertisement



REsources

From the Diabetes Hands Foundation blog...

Meet The 2014 Big Blue Test Grant Recipients

  This year Diabetes Hands Foundation has pledged US$35,000 in Big Blue Test grants, continuing its support for programs aimed at providing lifesaving supplies, medical tests, treatment, and patient education to people living in need who have or at risk Read on! →

Kim Vlasnik: The Patient Voice

  Kim Vlasnik, you NAILED it! In this video, Kim Vlasnik takes our breath away as she describes what its like to be a person with diabetes. Fortunately, Stanford’s Medicine-X Conference gives ePatients, like Kim, a chance to speak since we carry the Read on! →

Diabetes Hands Foundation Team

DHF TEAM

Manny Hernandez
(Co-Founder, Editor, has LADA)

Emily Coles
(Head of Communities, has type 1)

Mila Ferrer
(EsTuDiabetes Community Manager, mother of a child with type 1)

Mike Lawson
(Head of Experience, has type 1)

Corinna Cornejo
(Development Manager, has type 2)

Desiree Johnson  (Administrative and Programs Assistant, has type 1)

DHF VOLUNTEERS


Lead Administrator

Brian (bsc) (has type 2)


Administrators

Lorraine (mother of type 1)
Marie B (has type 1)

DanP (has Type 1)

Gary (has type 2)

David (has type 2)

 

LIKE us on Facebook

Spread the word

Loading…

This website is certified by Health On the Net Foundation. Click to verify. This site complies with the HONcode standard for trustworthy health information: verify here.

© 2014   A community of people touched by diabetes, run by the Diabetes Hands Foundation.

Badges  |  Contact Us  |  Terms of Service